He's not, actually, as much of a jerk as he plays on television. Mostly. And the guy seems harmless enough now they've chatted a bit, even if he did bring this on himself by letting Annie goad him into eating the stuff. (Then again, Finnick knows just how hard it is to resist Annie when she's in that sort of a mood.)

And the guy is choking so much on the stuff that he can't even admit he was wrong and ask for some ice-cream, so Finnick, smirking, is just about to reach for the cooler anyway when Annie pushes him towards it.

"Okay, okay," he laughs, and bends down to get the guy some, offering it out to the wildly gesturing hand.